The promised note on Albert Payson Terhune — with a name like that, he’d have to have been at least upper middle class, and he was, he was — and his dog books.
From Wikipedia:
Albert Payson Terhune (December 21, 1872 – February 18, 1942) was an American writer, dog breeder, and journalist. He was popular for his novels relating the adventures of his beloved collies and as a breeder of collies at his Sunnybank Kennels [in Wayne NJ], the lines of which still exist in today’s Rough Collies.
… The first of his novels about his dogs, Lad: A Dog, collected a dozen stories of his collie Lad in novel form [in 1919]. Lad was followed by over 30 additional dog-focused novels, including two additional books about Lad.
… Terhune is now often criticized for his starkly racist depictions of the minorities, hill people and so-called “half-breeds” that peopled parts of northern New Jersey less idealized than Sunnybank.
I’m pretty sure I got my copy of Lad as a gift from my father, who read it and loved it when he was a child (he was born in 1914). I treasured it on its own — I was a friend of dogs — and also because it came from him. I don’t remember the racism, but I did outgrow dog books eventually, choosing to give them away to younger kids when I went on to Princeton, where they would in any case have subjected me to ridicule.
I kept all the Oz books, but didn’t take them with me to Princeton. I was a highschooler, not a preppy; I was pretty obviously not long off the farm; I was working hard at many jobs to get through school; and I was ferociously talented academically — all of which inspired resentment and contempt (I was seen as cheapening the value of Princeton as a bastion of the elite — fortunately, not by everyone, so I managed to survive). Oz would have given off the stink of a prole childhood.
I foolishly tried to ape the cool of prep, though I did learn how to dress well in that style, which turned out to be an essential talent when I needed to fit in with the social elite of Lexington KY a few years later. The twists and turns of life are indeed strange.
Meanwhile, my choosing Princeton over Harvard went back to my admissions interviews, in which (as I recall it) I was, startlingly, recruited by two Nobel Prize winners and a Fields Medalist, all from the Institute for Advanced Study, three men who of course knew absolutely nothing about being an undergraduate at Princeton, but a hell of a lot about mathematics and physics (and steered me firmly away from my intentions to study chemistry, the arts, philosophy, and social sciences, the last three being the very things I wanted especially to get out of Princeton: an actual liberal education. Which I managed to extract anyway, and it was truly wonderful. One more time: the twists and turns of life are indeed strange.
August 27, 2026 at 10:54 am |
There’s a certain amount of what I’ll call “casual” racism in some of the Dr. Dolittle books, as I recall. And some years ago I decided to revisit Booth Tarkington’s “Penrod” books, another childhood favorite, and besides being put off by the unrelentingly arch tone, I was appalled at the treatment of the Black family that moved into the house behind Penrod’s family home.
August 27, 2026 at 11:15 am |
Yes. “Penrod” was a very unpleasant surprise.
August 28, 2026 at 7:39 am |
It seems like any time I can revisit a book from childhood (I was born in 1939) I’m appalled by the racism.
Particularly Stowaways in Paradise – Don Blanding’s book about two boys, a haole and a kanaka of around 13, hanging out in 1930s Hawaii. (But I still love that book – it’s on a shelf in front of me right now.)
August 29, 2026 at 12:04 pm |
Ah, that one I don’t know, though the premise sounds like it would have suited me. Sigh.
August 29, 2026 at 2:39 pm |
Don Blanding is known to have been gay. I think you can probably find the book online somewhere.
August 29, 2026 at 3:02 pm |
I’m a cheerleader for my people, but of course gay guys can run off the rails in appalling ways just as much as straight guys.
August 29, 2026 at 3:13 pm |
And now turns out that book counts as a rarity; used copies are available from several sources, but only at fabulous cost.
August 29, 2026 at 3:07 pm |
Don Blanding has a Wikipedia bio. I think it doesn’t mention his being gay.